Main | 9 approaches to explain Dark Romanticism: Psycho-analytic | Religious | Mystic  Philosophical | Romantic | Social | Inspirational | Sublime | Sitemap | Contact  

 
 


 

WHY THE DEVIATION FROM ROMANTICISM?

 

Why did Walpole, de Sade and Lewis deviate from the common ideals? Why were some authors obsessed with grotesquerie and obscurity during the romantic era? 

Below I summarized the general approaches to understand this deviation, next to my own approaches. I have defined Dark Romanticism as a philosophy in another section - here I analyze the historic deviation and the reasons for the origin of Dark Romanticism. To some degree they are variations of the same theme. Some of them are also quite unbelievable and should be understood as pure speculation and inspiration for further research. For further theorethical thoughts upon the subject, please follow this link




Psycho-analytic approach

During the romantic era, artists strived to express ideal beauty - ugliness was forbidden. One might argue that raising such bans also indirectly stimulates the interest in the banned. This simple approach suggests that if apples were forbidden, we would become obsessed by apples. Which may in fact be true. 



Mystic approach 

The medieval mystics believed they could decrease the distance to God in a state of excessive grief, distress and pain. Some associations in England and America believed that the horrible vampires and werewolfs came from a forgotten, distant world to awake us.    



Social approach

Oscar Wilde critized the hypocritical Victorian society - where people condemned the moral decay at tea partys and went directly to the brothels - in his novels. The reason, I believe, was not to demolish, but to improve, the Enligsh society. Marquis De Sade (L'ldee sur les Romans) argued that the gothic story was a consequence of the revolutions in Europe. Romantic novels could not describe the terrible human conditions at the time. Some theorists suggest that economic, social and scientific revolutions trigger movements in art and literature. 

Many Dark Romantics were socially concerned (Johnny Cash, William Blake). Many Dark Romantics were also poor, sick and addicted to drugs and alcohol. 



Sublime approach

During the romantic era Edmund Burke, among others, suggested that pain and danger delight us more than joy pleasure. Terror is the strongest emotion we are capable of feeling - consequently terror evokes the sublime.

 


Religious approach

Christian priests even today condemn foklore and popular belief. All supernatural supreme beings besides The Father, The Son and The Holy Ghost -  vampires, ghosts, werewolfs - are works of evil forces. 

The authors of the Bible states that a human being is vulnerable when she opens her heart to God in a prayer - only then the darker forces gets a chance to sneak in, sometimes disguised. Walpole, de Sade and Lewis were under the influence of Satan..



Philosophical approach

Romantic philosophers didn't believe in  apprehending truth with reason. Reason didn't solve any social problems. Instead, people believed in figments of imagination. Other philosophers suggest that the belief in reason - during the Age of Enlightenment - extinguished imagination. Nothing was scary during the Romantic era. People could read a horror story like any other story.  



Romantic approach

This approach suggests that the Dark Romantics didn't really deviate from Romanticism. They expressed ideal beauty as well. Nightmares were according to them more beautiful than daydreams. Dark Romanticism was a reaction against the sentimental and sometimes ignorant romantic novels.



Inspirational approach

Dark Romantics praised imagination and feeling - without any limits. Religious morality did not restrain the artists. Personally I prefer this rather simple approach - can we, or the romanticists two hundred years ago, really decide where our imagination shall take us?